Europe’s Challenge to the American Plan
America’s lack of regulation may, counterintuitively, be an advantage should regulation be desired in the global market
The American plan for AI removed the burden of discordant state regulation, placing instead a federal review on the export of AI technologies.
Without intrusive regulations, and with the capaciousness for training frontier models at an elite scale—thanks to galvanized US hyperscalers providing direct access to Nvidia GPUs—America’s Anthropic and OpenAI are beating out the capabilities of European challengers.
European Challengers
Aleph Alpha (via Germany) and Minstral (via France) are European answers to America’s closed frontier models.
These models are attractive to European companies as they provide off-the-shelf compliance with the EU AI Act. They could also attract global consumers who value off-the-shelf peace of mind that European regulation intrinsically offers for both security and social costs.
Aleph Alpha is tailored for highly regulated industries—such as defense, banking, and government—as it allows on-premise sovereignty.
Mistral aims to compete more directly with Anthropic and Open AI as a powerful general-AI model provider, yet compliant with European regulation and more affordable.
Reviewing the Global Competition
China’s plan is to provide the cheapest AI models for the global market that could also become the most powerful through recursive improvement enabled by high rates of adoption.
The American plan has been to remove the burden of regulation, marshall its build-tout to take advantage its distinct access to GPUs, and offer the best capabilities to approved consumers in the global market for a premium price.
China is leading in embodied AI but lagging behind the capabilities of American AI technologies.
The UK appears to be immediately focused on integrating American AI technologies across various domains through centralized institutions evenly spread out across the nation—ironically resembling America’s approach during the British Empire’s free trade dominance during the Industrial Revolution.
Europe’s plan is less monolithic than the competition, and unlikely to offer the most capacious models; yet, Europe may continue to produce models that stay competitive in performance and include regulation for an attractive offering.
The uncertainty is whether the increased competence of AI technologies always translates to increased opportunities.
If AI technologies require effective coordination, then the most performant models may not necessarily provide enough of an edge to justify the premium cost.
Europe’s Challenge
Europe’s opportunity is in its AI technologies with out-of-the-box regulation.
This could also turn out to be a weakness with respect to the global market—though overall economic success is not limited to winning the global market for AI models.
The British Empire dominated free trade during the Industrial Revolution, yet nations like American and France were able to effectively counter through a protectionist approach.
But AI’s impact may not be completely analogous with industrialization. The risks seem higher.
If history repeats itself, then nations will focus on primarily protecting themselves when risks are high.
Therefore, it becomes apparent that AI build-out requires intrusive regulation to thwart risks to defense, cybersecurity, and public interest, then nations will want to self-regulate rather than getting off-the-shelf regulation.
Europe’s pre-regulated technologies may be inconvenient and/or duplicative with regulation at home.
America’s Opportunity
Given that, America has an opportunity to provide the global market with the most powerful AI models and a gold standard apparatus for implementing regulation.
Just as US hyperscalers provided the apparatus for gold standard software implementation, AI companies grown in the US may provide gold standard platforms and tools so other nations can apply custom regulation to their technologies.
This means that the global market could couple premier US models and gold standard regulation tools. Or, they could pick and choose.
Now, there’s nothing preventing from the UK and Europe from providing this self-regulation apparatus.
However, the UK does not seem too focused on the global market, and Europe is forced to provide narrow regulation in its technologies.
America’s lack of regulation may, counterintuitively, be an advantage should regulation be desired in the global market.


Discussion about this post